Why AltFi mustn't forget its social purpose

  • google_profile_photo.jpg

    Institutional investment in Altfi has been back in the news recently with the FT reporting that that the P2PFA was taking steps to ban institutional 'cherry picking' - a practice that was quickly denied to exist in the UK by the main players such as Funding Circle and Zopa. 

    Many commentators argue that AltFi is hurtling towards banking at warp speed. They say this is inevitable as the institutions pour into the sector in the search for yield and introduce the ways of investment banking to further enhance returns and distribute risk. Securitisations and collateralised debt obligations have already appeared, even if not explicitly named as such, and one wonders how far away we are from the first credit default swap.

    Nobody is denying the industry's need to mature and the platforms' right to secure liquidity from any legitimate source, indeed, it is essential if we are to see a sustainable, broad-based and competitive financial services industry. But there is another really important point in play here and that is the social purpose of the AltFi industry, namely to re-engineer an uncompetitive and, some would say, morally bankrupt banking system, by directly connecting the individual investor with the creator of value - typically an ambitious SME.

    Lending to SMEs via peer-to-peer is socially useful - it creates jobs, it advances innovation and is a service to the community at large. The capital is used in the real economy for productive purposes and not for speculation in shadow banking products that nobody understands. That is its inherent beauty.

    True peer-to-peer lending, particularly local peer-to-peer lending, goes even further than this because it allows for due diligence in a very personal way: the lender can see how their money is being put to work to create the interest payments and the borrower knows who their lenders are.

    By re-connecting people with their money, Altfi has the potential to reduce the alienation that has become so characteristic of the banking industry. People are trusted to make the right decisions for themselves. Investors are given control to support the businesses they believe in and, as importantly, to refuse the ones they don't. Borrowers know that the money is coming from real people who are showing a tangible belief in them. To this extent the relationship between lender and borrower is genuinely mutualistic.

    If AltFi is going to contribute to a better society, it needs to view its role as being more than wealth creation for its own sake. It needs to be about reforming the values of the financial services sector, increasing the transparency of the system and directing money into activities that are understood and good. AltFi mustn't allow itself to become just another supplier of raw material to the investment banking value chain.

    The major UK platforms have remained very well balanced between retail and institutional money to date and long may this continue. By relying heavily on institutional money and, in turn, allowing those institutions to engage in financial engineering of their loans to create investment products, platforms risk re-constructing the emotional disconnect between the lender and borrower that exists in traditional banking. Not only does that raise the spectre of the banking crisis of 2007-8, it misses the opportunity for the biggest financial revolution in generations.

    Recent reading has included 'The Heretics Guide to Global Finance: Hacking the Future of Money' by Brett Scott (Pluto Press) and The End of Banking blog by Jonathan McMillan, both of which have inspired this article. Thanks to both.

Related articles

  • Read More

    Peer-to-Peer lending passes £10 billion mark

    Peer-to-peer lending has reached a significant milestone since Zopa launched the world’s first P2P platform in 2005. Over £10 billion has been cumulatively lent across 23 UK P2P platforms....

  • Read More

    Peer to Peer featured in Queen's birthday honours

    Good to hear that the pre-eminent pioneers of P2P lending in the UK are receiving formal recognition for their outstanding achievements. Described an a ‘Peer to Peer and Financial Inclusion...

  • Read More

    New Fintech Collaboration: Xero + Liberis

    Liberis, the card based finance provider, has announced an integration with Xero, the UK's leading online accounting software, to improve small businesses’ access to capital and credit....

  • Read More

    Consumer debt rises while businesses save

    Soaring levels of consumer debt are evidently causing the Bank of England, the Government and others in authority some sleepless nights. According to a recent report in The Guardian, the number of...

  • Read More

    Liberis and Sage launch Sage Pay Business Finance

    Sage Pay has teamed up with alternative business finance provider, Liberis,to give Sage customers access to flexible financing for the first time....

  • Read More

    ArchOver receives FCA authorization

    ArchOver, one of The Marketing Eye’s longest standing clients in the alternative finance sector, has been granted full authorisation by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). The news represents a...

  • Read More

    Australian Budget sets scene for FinTech growth

    The latest Budget statement from ‘down under’, on May 9, reaffirmed the Australian Government’s intention to turn the continent into a global fintech centre....

  • Read More

    FinTech as a force for good

    Kids, they say, grow up quickly and nowhere is this more true than in FinTech. Barely five years ago, the phrase wasn’t even invented. Now it is the collective noun for billion dollar enterprises,...

  • Read More

    What is a bank?

    One of the recurring themes at this year's AltFi Europe event, organised by the excellent AltFi team, was a quest for the definition of a bank, or more particularly a bank of the future. Is it any...

  • Read More

    Giles Andrews' appointment marks another step on P2P’s road to maturity

    Students of the history of finance may one day look back on Giles Andrews’ appointment to the Chair of MarketInvoice (MI) as a major milestone in the evolution of the P2P sector....

Take the first step

To find out more about how we can help you grow faster, please get in touch. We'd like to hear from you.  Or try our instant marketing healthcheck, it's free!

Quick Contact

Quick contact


Contact us

T 01825 765617

E hello@themarketingeye.com

Our offices

Full details of our offices in London and Uckfield more

Request a call